Who's the Better Rock Guitar Player, Josh Homm...
Feed
«
»
Image 1 of 4


Author: Rusty Shackleford
Started: May 24, 2005, 9:05:59 pm
Target: Petition Spot
Category: Entertainment & Media
Supporters:

20
Goal:

24
Goal Progress:

84% Complete
Status

Closed
Right now in my opinion, there are two really great rock guitar players in the 28-32 year old age bracket making great rock music by playing and writing their own material, Josh Homme of Queens of the Stone Age and Jack White of the White Stripes. Both are strong player and writers, but which do you think is the best of the two. Please confine this discussion to only these two players as we all know that there are 100's of great guitar players of many genres and ages out there, past and present.




Acne Life Insurance Death Insurance Bextra Asbestos Car Insurance Dental Plans 0 Private Jets Debt Consolidation credit Cards Rewards Cards Equity Loans Equity Line credit Loans Mortgages Pay Day Loans Cash Advance 0 Bankruptcy Reduce Debt Refinance Jet Charter Vioxx Wrongful death Legal Advice Taxes Investing Bonds 0 Online Trading IRA Rollover Refinance Quotes Adult Education Distance Learning Alcohol Treatment Rehab Drug Rehab Spyware Cell Phone Plans 0 Calling Cards VOIP Weight Loss Canadian Pharmacy Depression Spam Filter Lasik Facelift Teeth Whitening Annuity 0 Anti Virus Protection Adult Diaper Free credit Report credit Score Satellite Anti Spam Software Dedicated Hosting Domain Name Need Money Bachelor Degree 0 Master Degree Doctorate Degree Work at Home Quick Book Extra Money Eloan Malpractice Lawyer Lenox China Cancer Payperclick 0 Personal Injury Attorney Lexington Law Video Conferencing Transfer Money Windstar Cruise Casinos Online Term Life Online Banking Borrow Money Low Interest credit Cards 0 Personal Domain Name Cellular Phone Rental Internet Broker Trans Union Cheap Hosting University Degrees Online Online Marketing Consolidate Helpdesk Software Web Host 0 Homeowner's Insurance Yellow Page Advertising Travel Insurance Register Domain credit Counseling Email Hosting Business credit Consumer credit Blue Cross Laptop Computer
Sign this Petition!    Spread the Word!


Recent Activity
26 seconds ago Cindy Moss SIGNED
34 seconds ago chris stanford SIGNED
1 minute ago SIGNED
2 minutes ago Tamzin V SIGNED
2 minutes ago Brenin Watts SIGNED


Discussion Forum
View all Topics Start a New Topic
There are no discussion topics, would you like to post one?

Signatures
andy said 08/25/05, 8:13 am (verified)
You can't judge this one without seeing Jack White live. He is amazing live, his albums dont' do him justice.
#20

Ben said 08/10/05, 6:48 pm (verified)
Tricky one. Both have amazingly unique sytles/sounds. Both use classy vintage amp tech. I would have to give it to Josh because he is so distictive. One note and you know who you are litening to. Dont get me wrong I LOVE Jack White's sound and they are both technically excellent guitarists.
#19

drew said 08/09/05, 12:30 pm (verified)
uh i'm gonna have to say that omar rodriguez of the mars volta is better than both of them, but jack is still cool
#18

Arnold said 08/09/05, 12:28 pm (verified)
I've been thinkin' bout my doorbell. when ya gonna ring it, when ya gonna ring it
#17

Luke said 08/02/05, 10:45 am (verified)
Josh Hommes without a doubt. The Stripes are great but Josh Hommes' stuff is much more technical (and at times Jack gets pretty repetitive).
#16

sum yung guy said 07/24/05, 8:25 pm (verified)
Josh homme definitly
#15

meg said 07/24/05, 10:43 am (verified)
jack white. he is the fucking best. i'm not biased about the white stripes being my fave band...ooh noo! lol. but yeah, he is also the hottest
#14

mary said 07/13/05, 1:10 pm (verified)
mr Joshua Homme esq.
#13

Nils Henrik said 06/24/05, 12:58 pm (verified)
Jack withe is a exelent guitar player..... and ha has been playing since he learned to walk..... yes his acords is easy to play....; and maybe for a 14 year ol kid..... but belive me.... seeing him live and doin solos is fucking great..... o shod off marshalldillon...... i am a pro, and have been playing guitar since i was 8 yaers old..... but with all respect josh homme is natural talent when it comes to guitar playing he is a god; but jack white is better
#12

sarah said 06/20/05, 11:14 am (verified)
josh
#11

grass said 06/17/05, 10:47 pm (verified)
Josh has this all the way. The White stripes are one of the most overated bands of all time.
#10

Erin said 06/16/05, 5:52 pm (verified)
Jack White has to have this one. I saw him live two years ago and it simply had to be the best show I ever went to, the best guitar playing I'd ever seen. Josh Homme is more minimalist (much as Jack would like to be), but Jack White is the better guitar player.
#9

Joey said 06/02/05, 8:56 pm (verified)
Wow, the QOTSA and the White Stripes are my two favorite bands. I think both Josh and Jack are EXCELLENT musicians. However, I think the Jack White is the better guitar player just because of his sheer knowledge of music and different styles.
#8

US_Marshall_Wyatt said 06/02/05, 3:23 am (verified)
Jack White. Dillon, minimalism is what IS rock and roll. With all do respect to Josh Homme who is a god too.
#7

MarshallDillon said 05/31/05, 4:31 pm (verified)
Ermm... excuse me? Jack White can write songs. Josh Homme is a guitar god. I have a 14 year old buddy who was able to play his licks in a few minutes, and thatīs not a joke. Donīt confuse minimalism with little guitar skills.
#6

Sara said 05/27/05, 2:34 pm (verified)
#5 stick to the topic. My vote goes for Josh Homme, however I'll be buying the new White Stripes album when it comes out too.
#5

Brandon said 05/27/05, 2:29 pm (verified)
Josh for technical prowless and cleaner playing, Jack for his slide work and bluesy minimalism. Both are strong songwriters, however QOTSA has a more complicated sound, where as with the Stripes it's down to the basics of blues based rock and roll.
#4

Ruth Ann said 05/27/05, 2:02 am (verified)
JACK WHITE
#3

Liz said 05/25/05, 4:33 pm (verified)
I will always be for Jack White. His greatest strength is in his creativity in writing and playing. The sound created bu that one guitar amazes me!
#2

Conrack said 05/24/05, 9:05 pm (verified)
I personally think that Josh Homme is the better guitar player. His playing is more controlled unlike Jack White whose playing is sloppy and more noisy.
#1