Wow how gay is this. Who the hell cares if Joel went out with hilary? Its his choice. [Fyi they arnt even together anymore] Okay how in the world can you feel screwed over. Is in manditory for every single celebrity to update the world on their personal lifes? Is there a rule somwhere that joel HAD to admit he was going out with hilary? I dont blaim him for 'lieing'. He has a life. And if your all pissed because he went out with hilary and didnt tell the world then you were NEVER a fan. You were just one of those little girls only likeing good charlotte because joel is hot. Its about there music NOT about there personal life so seriosuly stfu and i should make a petition to make people like you shut your mouths. Thanks.

FUCK YOU 'Baby' (what kind of name is that anyway???) Noone likes joel MADDEN do they? STOP TALKING CRAP THOUSANDS OF PEOPLE, INCLUDING ME, LOVE HIM. And why was this petition made anyway? Joel doesnt have to tell us every fucking thing about him. He can keep some bloody secrets, yknow.

because joel madden is a friggin virgin you idiots... check the promise ring. if he wasnt a virgin, he would take the ring off.

joels a vergin idiots

joel madden is the hottest guy ever and i love him more then everything in the werld put together dso screw yu all!!!!!!

THEY ARE NOT AND I LIKE JOEL MADDEN SO SHUT YOU BIG FAT UGLY MOUTH

GOOD CHARLOTTE ARE POSERS THEY SUCK RAT NIPPLES I HATE THEM NOBODY LIKES JOEL MADDAN NE WAY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!

you are all a bunch of freaks gc are awsome and that will never change SHE made him like this it was Hilary

Barbeque Trout and Good Charlotte are both fucking gay.

ohh yeah Trout, great idea. Damn, I already thought of that say... 3 months ago?

Theres this thing called: He's a grown man, and he can do whatever he wants. Don't like it? Don't be a fan! End of story.