because...ok, yeah, Dumbledore did need to die so that Harry can do this on his own, but SIRIUS IS ALIVE!!! Come on, you ALL know you looked for those clues in the 5th and 6th books and in JKR's interviews... but yes, I loved Dumbledore and Sirius and would love to see them both back and to have a happy ending :-)
I agree! Do not rag on her because she killed off a character be thankful that she created this world that you yourself enjoy to read and find out more anout the world. leave her alone
Did she kill them of to torment us? We deserve or charaters back! She killed them Pointlessly. NO! Ithink as fans of Harry Potter you should take a good hard look at yourselves. She created this wonderful magical world that she wanted to share with the world. Sure she toke away a charater that you loved and charished but all great writters do that at some stage. J.K.Rowling had an idea a story that she decided to share with others that would expand there imagination that would open there eyes to a whole new meaning to the word of Magic. And it did! Hundreds of children, teenagers and Adults around the globe toke a interest in Harry Potter. So did you. All she wanted to do was make children believe again and so many children now do, she doesn't mean to upset you when she toke away Sirius and Albus but a Great writter like Joanne would have something up her sleeve for the next book. You do not deserve your characters ack ( her characters accually) you are all a discrace if you even say you read the harry potter books or that your a fan or if you own the dvd because being cruel to the one person that created Sirius that made him who he was and is, is just plain dispicible. I think to say J.K.Rowling is a privalige and i say it with pride, so should you. Think about it!
I support this petition. You guys are sooo mean! what if this really works and dumbledore and sirius comes back?! I know it would make loads of people happy if they did!
Okay... Sirius and Dumbledore kinda DID need to die. To convince Harry to go on his quest to defeat Voldemort and his Death Eaters. In a way, Voldy's sorta killing everyone Harry cares about, (his parents, Sirius, Dumbledore...) and that gives Harry the desire to defeat HIM. Make sense?
I would love to see Sirius come back... because Harry's life it really too tragic (even if it is only a story i know). I mean come on... give the boy a break! As for Dumbledore, i suppose it was only a matter of time because the prophecy does say that it is ultimately Harry who has to kill Voldemort or die trying. My 2 cents worth.
The thing is. you could sign this petition 232434900 times and nothing will come of it. I agree that people should have there own free speech but this is slightly going over the top. Jo obviously had a reason to kill Dumbledore so she did.
Same goes for Sirius.
oh dear god i just read a post by one snow theyre literary characters they do not have feelings they do not exist and she created them thats what gives her the right to kill them off
characters die in dark storys it makes since i knew dumbledore was gonna die and i could smelll sirius's demise its good for character development with harry there noyt youre characters by the way there hers so she has said they shall stay dead
"a hard top with a decint engine and make sure its got a big trunk!"
- Dwight SIN CITY
No baby, no one wants to watch some creepy, skeletal, half-mad fella on their webcam. Even if he is Sirius Black.
But they do wanna watch a handsome, well-built and quite sane babe on their webcam. Especially a pre-Azkaban Sirius Black.
Honey, if your gonna get anyway with your petition, you better be getting some better promo pictures for starters.
Thank you so much for this petition!!!
JKR is ruining her books by making all the best characters die, first Sirius, now Dumbledore. She has no right to kill these wonderful characters, they have feelings too.
I like to think this is a joke, but I'm afraid there's actually some truth to it. If your romances mean this much to you perhaps you should be reading Jackie Collins instead of JK Rowling. Call my producers. I think you need help.
My reading of the entire HP books is now down in flames, all my experiences of imagination – experiences in fiction unlike you will ever be conscience of - are now destroyed because of your vastly overpublished knife twisting known as HBP.
In the very slight possibility that JKR reads this, I just want to say - thank you for a wonderful book, Jo, best in the series so far! Keep on with the series! I hope Harry gets back together with Ginny again, because he deserves the joy and happiness she clearly gives him.
Grow up, kids. It's a fictional work, and JKR, as the author, has every right to write it the way she wants - she clearly always intended it to be Ron and Hermione, and the majority of fans could see that. And anyway, if you think Ron and Lavender "seemed real", then you're clearly not fit to judge any literary romance. GROW UP.
You're getting worked up over a game. Why don't you all take a break from the computer and enjoy some fresh air? I'm sure you need it.
Not only is this getting worked up over something virtual, but it's something that is very stupid. People can hate what they want. Let them. You cannot change the way other people think by cussing them out and starting a petition, now can you? I don't think so.
I would like to say
Freedom of speech is somethimg many enjoy. While this is part of the enjoyment it is also a sad sad sad fragment of hate that has ruined our fair country.
I cry and wish that everyone would see their mistakes and not abuse their rights but sadly idiots like your selves have.
A tear passes my chin.
You need to see the light.
America is a great country. Let British alike enjoy their rights yet don't please dont abuse them.
I hope that you will learn from this.
I hope I have changed many thank you.
OMG OMG OMG you guys are dumb look at this: "I'm JK rowling and I think ur shit so fuck you"
an2ways i think ur all stupid so there. I think rowling finds this really really dumb haha
Omg guys u know the truth stop lieing to ur selves and htanks supporters!
Dumbledore is right thou Im so unorganized!
okay so sirius should come back maybe not dumbledore! dumbledore was old lolz
im so sad :(:(:(
i neally cried when dumbledore died and sirius jst the sames but....there gone and they aint cumin bck so i wud gt ova it b4 it depresses u furtha.
there gone so we r gonna have 2 gt through r grife and b strong.
blub bulb :(
You are so right...she has simply gone too far..she must be stopped and of course she must be prevented from writing her own novels!! We must all band together...to save the world from her evil doings!
By the way Chritina i love you, your fucking hilarious!!
Sadly, your minds seem to be rather unorganized. I suggest a course in the well-organized mind, for then you shall realise there is no need to ask for me back, I have embarked on the next great adventure (aka the flighty temptress).
Thank you for your concern. But you would do better if you put your energy into saving the rainforest.
I think the plot she's had in mind for years is a just a BIT MORE IMPORTANT than a stupid small crowd, huh. If you don't like the pairing or Sirius and Dumbledore dying... JUST DON'T READ BOOK SEVEN! It's not like it will affect her a couple of retards don't buy her book. What are you, like five?
Okay thats enuff! I'm FUCKING PISSED. You are ALL DUMB and im christen and this pisses me off Jesus you peace of shit
this is a stupid joke im gonna kill all of u
i fucking hate this
You guys need to learn a lesson about whos books whos and not.
For one miss Rowling is a respected individual and shes more rich than all of you
for another you dont no what your talking about so haha
anyways in all miss rowling is better than you so SUCK IT
