I DO NOT SUPPORT THIS PETTION .How seriously dumb can you be. I think David Thewlis is perfect for the role and if you put Tom Cruise in the whole movie would be ruined. Plus Tom is really ugly.

Tom Cruise???? That nutter? A crazy scientologist who honestly thinks he's Jesus Christ? You want him to play Lupin, one of the best characters in HP? Wow, you must have a few screws loose.

I FUCKD YA MAS HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHHHHHHHHHH HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH HHHHHHHHHHHHHHAAAAAAAAAAA AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA AAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH HHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHH HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH HHHHHHHHHHHH

This is only *one* of the stupid petitions you have up here. I don't know why the time and effort; it is NOT going to happen. People have posted that here and I'm going to echo - NEVER.

i DONT support this but something has GOT to be said!! they should BAN ALL OTTER SNOW PETITIONS AND THE ONES THAT AREADY EXIST SHOULD BE DELETED!! the only reason u have signatures is because u have a spot on the mugglenet WALL OF SHAME if u didnt know... go to the mugglenet special edition wall of shame and i reccomend all potter h8ers to go the 1st wall of shame ok im speeking on the behalf of every true potter fan...now...listen VERY closley... no matter how many petitons u make on this gay-ass site it WONT make a difference! JKR WILL finish writing the sereis wether u like it or not Warner Bros WILL finish filming the seris with what ever actors THEY WANT (lets hope it stays Rupert, Emma, Dan and everyone else 2!!)so if u like the movies/actors or not they r gonna be released and theyll be the most popular movies EVER, Hp 4 DVD r ALREADY in the guiness book of world records for the fastest selling DVD ever and when Order of The Pheonix comes out on DVD it will top it u and laura mallory should make a " lets-be-the-2-gayest-ppl- on-earth-and-try-and-ban- the-Hp-series-cuz-we-thin k-it-sucks" club so to sum it all up... BUILD A BRIDGE AND GET OVER IT!!!!!!! i dont in any way shape or form support this petition or otter snow i think she is a delusional freak that needs to get a life, be BANNED from this website and everyother petition or Hp site on the web AND take a knight bus 2 St. Mungos ASAP PROUD harry potter fanatic PROUDER mugglenet member PROUDEST laura mallory/otter snow H8ER Luv Potter Luv Hogwarts Luv Gryffindor PeAcE ps. harry potter is a BRITISH book writen by a BRITISH author therefor the actors should be BRITISH.....like me=) o and i totally agree w/ U R A FUCKER (the person who posted b4 me =))

1. David Thewlis is a better Lupin than anyone else in the entire wolrd would ever be. 2. Tom Cruise does not have European Accent and they made a point to make sure that in casting all actors accents must be REAL 3. If a Harry Potter movie was ever banned becaues one retarded motherfucker (YOU) didn't like DavidThewlis, I'd hunt them down. 4. You are retarded. Passionately retarded. You are the living embodiment of retardedness. So take your wrist, put it to your chest and live the rest of your life saying Dee-dee-dee. David Thewlis will reamin Remus Lupin until he either dies or the series ends. GET THE FUCK OVER IT! your petition is a waster bandwitch and you are a waste of semen. Your parens should not have reproduced.

I support this petition.

I found some errors in your statement so I thought I'd would correct them for you. 1. "We Want Tom Cruise for Lupin!" - Who is we? Your nickname? You're the only one supporting this. 2. "fangirl's dream was shattered" - No it wasn't 3. David Thewlis?Who??? - The guy who played Einon in Dragonheart and various movies like The Omen that came out this year and Kindgom of Heaven in 05 - Just because you only live in LA under the hollywood sign, doesn't mean the rest do. 4. "hunkmeister Tom Cruise" - I wonder if you're a guy or girl now.. 5. "Therefore, we have no choice but to ban all future Harry Potter movies until Tom Cruise is hired to play Lupin." - Oh yeah.. I see that happening. The headline will read: Moron attempts to ban Harry Potter movies. You seriously need to re think your life. You made me laugh so hard by reading this.

I support this petition.

O...k you are dumber than I thought! Tom Cruise SUCKS!!! I hated David Thewlis too but Damn there could be better actors than Tom Cruise!!! Like I still say that Johnny Depp should have played Sirius Black but JKR was PROMISED an ALL ENGISH CAST!!!!

Yep, I'm thoroughly convinced that you, otter snow, are either under 10 or have the brain span of someone at that age. Stop forcing your opinions like they include everyone. Thewlis has that shabby look that Lupin requires, and you think pretty-boy Tom Cruise fits the bill? Please.

Shut the fuck up you litte fuckhead. Go get a life. Dumbass.

blow that bitches e-mail up!

Go fuck yourself. You are not a fan of Harry Potter. Write your own goddamn books. I'm sure they'll FLY off the shelf. You fucking cow.

This is the most stupid petition I've ever seen! No, that's not true, the Harry/Hermione one was that. Tom Cruise couldn't handeled to play a so special character as Remus Lupin! Okey, David Thewlis doesn't look a bit like my Remus, but he still did a great job. Tom Cruise is just a goodlooking fanatic! Someone plaing RL have to have a brain!

Wow another stupid petition from Otter snow. fuck off you bitch.

Haha. Tom Cruise cannot ever pull of Lupin. He does not have the accent, or the look.

otter snow, is it your purpose in life to come up with the most stupid, ridiculous HP petitions this side of the North Pole? Cause you've done it. it's getting to the point where i don't even know if you're joking or not. yes. it's that stupid. tom cruise for lupin? robin williams for dumbledore? are you trying to rewrite the book and recreate the movies? newsflash. the world doesn't revolve around you. you didn't write the book. you didn't make the movies. DEAL WITH IT. freak.

hey i don't like David Thewlis either...i definitely think Lupin should been better-looking. Tonks falling in love w/ David Thewlis? thats just kind of...gross. but Tom Cruise??? LOL. he's AMERICAN. please. only Brit actors for the HP movies, please! and Lupin isn't supposed to be a hunk...just younger than Thewlis, and probably a wee bit cuter. so i understand your sentiment, otter. but you need to use your brain more often, pal.

Tom Cruise doing a British accent???? I just don't see that happening...convincingly anyway...