Well the truth is, Hilarie Duff is one of the worlds largest wannabes so I have no idea why she was slagging of Amy Lee cause at the end of the day, Hilarie is just like a pathetic child who has 5 year olds as her main fans. Lindsay isnt the best person in the world, I admit, but I could stand her and Avril is cool, and Amy Lee is awesome. Also, wasnt Hilarie the one dying her black, trying to be goth? Hmm, I dont see the logic there...

Amy lee ain't freaky she is the best singer out of all of them she's my favorite. the rest of them I'm not much interested in.

I support this petition.

I DON"T support this Petition.

Amy lee rocks! hat lindsey bu t like her hair. Hillary is okay and Avril has just changed I miss the old her. Amy lee is goth but she ain't freaky like Marilyn manson.

AMY LEE is a big comparison to the other ones. Shes more mature, not to mention a HEAP more talented. Evanescence rocks! She has to be the best singer alive, no one can beat her amazing voice. She is a very down to earth person actually, and AMY LEE IS NOT GOTH AND FREAKY. She is barely goth at all, only the music has a touch of it. Huh, Amy lee could beat any of those ppl hands down.

AMY LEE has the greatest voice i have ever heard!!!! she is amazing. AND she plays the piano!! how great is that?? her voice is soo powerful and she puts so much emotion into her songs!! i just hope that i could be like her someday!! YA RITE.. no one could top her!!! she is soo amazing!!!

Amy Lee is wayyyyyyy better than Hillary, Avril, and Lindsey Put Together. She can acually sing, unlike SOME people. What instrument can Hilary or Lindsay play? Thats right, they can't play anything! And don't even start to tell me that Avril can play guitar, because she CAN'T!!! 2 cords doesn't count as playing. And something else that none of them can do is write there own lyircs! Amy's inspirational and has meaning to her stuff. Her songs have changed people's lives. Has

amy lee and she has a lot more talent then a strand of hlarys hair and shes a good romodel for teen and isnt scary and doesnt scare little childran your weird if u thnk shes scary my 2 year old brother doesnt and she isnt paper thin unlike hilary right now who looks like a skeleton and she can sing hilary only has one pitch play piano and writes her own song and hilary does none o these i lost all respect for hilary a long time ago, she also has more fans than hilary and is a lot more beautiful and sings about real things people can relate too sorry amys better

Evanescence has a hand on everyone. no one can sing better than they do and no one should try. they are their own self and and they make their own sound. they dont try to copy anyone else and they are an inspiration to all the other girls that just wanna ROCK!!!

the other chicks suck hillery has the nerve to rip on lee she is stupid. avril songs are gay and she dreeses like a looser a punk chick with a tie there is something kind of cool about amy's choice of clothing but avril is just dreesing like a duchebag she looks like an ediot evry where she goes she should not have even been given a record deal she is as bad as paris hilton and ashlee simpson

this pettition is a descrace to amy lee to lump her in with these three other loosers is just redicouls she has more talent than all three of these chicks combined lindsay hillery and avril suck hillary is a prissy pussy who cn't shut her trap she sounds work than a whiny dog lindsay is a slut and shitty actress and avril is just an angry bitch who thinks she is tough all of their music sucks and each of them are sluts avril was flashing her ass at the music awards and was actually dumbenough to have her ass hanging out while performing I hate avril with a passion she sucks lee is the most talented with her grundge kind of music and classy appeal these other loosers are not worthy to be compared to her espically avril she is not even hot she is a pig face whore

I have to agree with all you guys, AMY LEE is a true INSPARATION(that is spelled wrong sorry - im from South Africa!!)She is one of the few celebrities who doesn't chance her apearence just to be a "hollywood slut" or a "Beverly Hills" brat. she is who she is, AMAZING, TRUE, HONEST, A REAL ROLEMODEL, A INSPARATION. She has something other celebs don't even try to get - Respect!!!!!! Keep rocking on amy............ Hope i make it to your show in South Africa;Capetown

ilove amy lee and avril hope to visit here in philippines

OBVIOUSLY AMY LEE cause she is so pretty, she can sing wonderfully. she is a good role model. good song writer. nice, funny. Amy has one of the most sought-after voices ever. she makes her own dresses. she doesn't show her self off in anyway. if you know about Everybody's fool. she sings about her emotions and how she feels. and like experiences. I Have been to one of her concerts and it was amazing. Amy isn't goth or any thung like that she just dresses like that to promote the image of the band. they have actually won 2 grammys. their fallen album has sold over 14 million. their newest album The Open Door has probably gone platinum. Amy has started her own organization fund for epilepsy and her brother has it. she has taken piano lessons for 9 years. The band has an awesome dvd live cd. it looks so cool and actaully sounds good.

I'm agreeing with Antonia. It's Amy Lee Hands down. Besides, if someone just says that another is freaky doesn't make them that way. 'Sides Amy Lee isn't an enemy of Hilary, she has made no comment towards her that I know of...

Avril

Wow your comment on Amy Lee was just SO mature 'She's just goth and freaky (like Hilary says)' aren't you SUCH a clever girl. Anyway my sarcastic nature influenced that. Amy Lee is the best person on that list. She;s the only person with any amount of talent on that list. Plus she is kind, caring, beautiful, funny and herself. She writes lyrics with so much powerful emotions streaming through them. I'd love to know how "If the light's not on, then its off" is a good set of lyrics. "Without the mask, where will you hide, can't find yourself, lost in your lie" is a good set of lyrics, all of Amy's lyrics are amazing and truthful and real. Plus Amy can actually sing live, she can sing live very well even with bronchitus. And also if you're so immature to dislike someone because of how they dress then you have lost all respect from me (not that you had much anyway) because I get bullied by enough people because of how I dress (which is quite similar to Amy's style, though I add my own elements as well) and you seem like one of those people. Not everyone is a manufactured MTV pop-princess drone, some people are actually unique and like to do things their own special way (with the help of the band of course, there are four other members - John, Rocky, Tim and Terry, formerly including Ben, Will and David) You know what if I can see Hilary Duff produce a song that can cpature an emtion that has more intelligence than 'OMG I, lyk, lost my boyfriend *tear tear*' Then help write the music for said lyrics, then perform it live (without lip-singing) as well as playing another instrument (and no holding a guitar for a photo-shoot DOESN'T count) then she may gain a shred of respect from me. But until that time she is a repulsive, bitchy, un-intelligent, mummy's girl. Just another pop-princess poseur who will eventually

AMY LEE

All are repulsive.