Why have a top 12 and only let the top 10 go? That is like saying since Fantasia is the winner Diana shouldn't go because she is not the winner, and that is dumb becasue Diana is very talented, so is Matt just because he was voted off so soon doesn't mean he isn't. He was chosen out of 70,000. Doesn't that mean something?

Clay Aiken should have one "American Idol 2" Clay deserved it! I couldn't get through for Clay. I couldn't get through this season either.

I would so buy the album I think Matt is Great!!!!!

Clay Aiken is amazing! From his voice to his book to his looks to the things he does for everyone. He totally deserves to have a star on the walk of fame! I have always wanted to be a famous singer and he inspires me even more to reach for my dreams. Especailly because I could work with him! I